- Faerie Tolkien Fanfiction
Busy, friendly archive with a great variety of fics.
- Silmarillion Writers’ Guild
- Of Elves and Men
Lots of great old fics there.
- Many Paths to Tread
A Tolkien archive with a LotR bias
- King and Herald
Stories featuring Elrond and Gil-galad — not updated in years but still worth a visit.
- Maggie’s Place
A writer long gone from the fandom, but everyone needs to read at least one Maggie-fic.
- Middle Earth Fanfiction Awards archive
The MEFAs are no longer with us, but the archive remains, complete with reviews. Thousands of Tolkien fics to dip into.
Begun in 2004 and still running, and featuring some of the best Tolkien fiction around.